Nifty slips for an eighth straight week — should you stop your SIP?

The Nifty has now fallen for eight weeks in a row, and the SIP stop button looks tempting. The short answer: stopping a SIP because the market is falling means you stop buying at prices lower than before. Here is why, with numbers.

What the Nifty actually did

The Nifty 50 index (the price level, without dividends) closed at 22,422 on 1 October 2026, down 0.88% on the day and lower for the eighth week in a row. Markets were shut on 2 October. Groww shows a 52-week high of 26,373, so the index sits about 15% below it.

A fall like this feels worse for people who started SIPs recently. It is not a reason to panic, because a SIP is built for exactly this kind of market.

How a SIP buys in a falling market

A SIP puts in the same rupee amount every month. When the fund's NAV (the price of one unit) is low, your money buys more units. When it is high, it buys fewer. This is called rupee cost averaging.

An illustrative example

These are made-up NAVs, not any real fund. Assume a ₹10,000 monthly SIP in an index fund. The NAV falls from ₹100 to ₹75 over six months, then recovers to ₹110 by month 12.

Month NAV (₹) Units bought --------- 1 100 100.0 2 95 105.3 3 90 111.1 4 85 117.6 5 80 125.0 6 75 133.3 7 78 128.2 8 84 119.0 9 90 111.1 10 96 104.2 11 103 97.1 12 110 90.9

- Total invested: ₹1,20,000 - Total units: about 1,343 - Your average cost: about ₹89.4 per unit (the simple average of the 12 NAVs is ₹90.5) - Value at NAV ₹110: about ₹1,47,700, a gain of about 23%

Notice that the lowest NAV bought the most units. Month 6 gave 133 units, while month 1 gave 100. A low NAV does not mean a fund is cheap. It only means your fixed amount buys more units that month.

Stop after six months, or keep going?

Now suppose you stopped after month 6, when the fall felt worst. You invested ₹60,000 and hold about 692 units. The two SIP choices put in different amounts, so look at the rupee result, not just the percentage. The lump-sum row is there for comparison.

Choice Money in Value if NAV ends at ₹110 Value if NAV ends at ₹90 ------------ Stop after month 6 ₹60,000 about ₹76,200 about ₹62,300 Keep the SIP for 12 months ₹1,20,000 about ₹1,47,700 about ₹1,20,900 One lump sum of ₹1.2 lakh at NAV ₹100 ₹1,20,000 ₹1,32,000 ₹1,08,000

Read the last column carefully. If the NAV recovers only to ₹90, which is still 10% below where it started, the continuing SIP roughly breaks even. The lump sum is down 10%. If the NAV recovers fully, the SIP that kept going earned about ₹27,700, against about ₹16,200 for the one that stopped. The difference comes from the six extra instalments, which were bought at NAVs from ₹78 to ₹110 and added about ₹11,500 of profit. Costs, tax and inflation are not counted here.

The one thing to remember A SIP does not protect you from a fall. It lowers your average cost while prices are falling, but only for the instalments you actually keep paying.

When a SIP does not help

Rupee cost averaging is not magic. Be honest about its limits:

- It needs a recovery. If the fund never gets back above your average cost, you still lose money, only less than a lump sum would. - It does not fix a poor fund. A SIP in a fund that keeps lagging its benchmark just keeps buying a weak fund. - Stopping can be right for the wrong reason, too. If your goal is less than three years away, or you may need the money soon, equity SIPs carry real risk whatever the market does.

What a sensible response looks like

Before you touch your SIP, check these points:

- Is the goal still far away? As a rough rule of thumb, for goals five years or more away, short falls matter less. Even then, how much you hold in equity should match how much loss you can bear. - Is your emergency fund in place? Many people stop SIPs only because they ran short of cash. A common rule of thumb is six months of expenses outside equity. Your own need depends on how steady your income is. - Can you still afford the instalment? If not, reduce the amount instead of cancelling. You keep the habit and the units. - Is the fund the problem? Compare it with its benchmark and peers over several years, not eight weeks.

For a sense of what stock returns look like over long periods, FundsIndia lists the Nifty 50 TRI (the index return including dividends) at about 12.0% a year (CAGR) over 10 years and 11.6% over 20 years, as of 31 August 2026. The same FundsIndia table shows 8.3% over five years and -0.4% over one year, so recent returns have been far weaker than the long run. These are past figures, not a forecast. The illustration above does not assume any of them. It only shows how units are bought.

Eight losing weeks hurt, but they are a short part of a long SIP. If your plan and your cash flow are unchanged, the plan usually asks you to keep going.

Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Sources

- https://www.bajajbroking.in/share-market-news/trade-setup-for-tomorrow - https://www.internationalnewsandviews.com/stock-market-today-october-1-2026-409918-2/ - https://groww.in/indices/nifty - https://fundsindia.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/202609-FundsIndia-Wealth-Conversations.pdf