Rent or buy a home in India: a ₹1 crore flat on a loan versus ₹25,000 rent plus a SIP. Who is richer after 20 years?
Should you buy a ₹1 crore flat with a home loan, or rent a similar one for ₹25,000 a month and invest the rest? Here is a worked example over 20 years. The answer depends on one number: how fast the flat's price grows each year. That number is about 7.9% a year in this example. If the flat grows faster than that, buying wins. If it grows slower, renting and investing wins.
This is an illustration with stated assumptions, not a forecast and not a real person's story.
The setup
Two people earn the same salary and want the same ₹1 crore flat to live in.
Item Buyer Renter --------- Flat Buys at ₹1 crore Rents a similar flat at ₹25,000 a month Money at the start ₹20 lakh down payment plus ₹6 lakh for stamp duty, registration and brokerage (about 6%, which varies by state) The same ₹26 lakh, invested on day one Loan ₹80 lakh at 8.5% for 20 years None Monthly cost EMI of ₹69,426 plus ₹4,000 for society charges and property tax Rent of ₹25,000 What happens to the gap Nothing The extra ₹48,000 or so a month goes into a SIP
More assumptions, all grown yearly: rent and society charges rise 5% a year. The renter's SIP earns 10% a year. The flat's price rises at a rate we change below.
How it was worked out (my own sums): each month the renter invests the gap between the buyer's total outgo (EMI plus society charges) and the rent. The ₹26 lakh lump sum and the monthly gap both grow at 10% a year, compounded monthly. The buyer's flat value is ₹1 crore grown at the stated yearly rate. Repairs and renovations are left out for both.
Where the numbers come from:
- Home loan rate. Rates quoted in October 2026 range from about 7.2% (Bank of Baroda) through 7.5% to 8.8% (SBI) and 8.0% to 9.1% (Axis). We use 8.5%. Check your own bank's live rate. - Rent. ₹25,000 a month on a ₹1 crore flat is a 3% gross rental yield (before society charges and property tax). Anarock's 2026 report puts yields at 3.2% (Delhi) to 4.6% (Bengaluru) in six big cities. - Return on the SIP. The Nifty 50 total-return index gave about 12.4% a year over 10 years and 20 years (NSE data as shown on Bajaj AMC's page, July 2026 and February 2026). We use 10% to stay below that. Real funds can earn less, and returns are not guaranteed. - Flat price growth. Anarock's report shows average prices from 2019 to the second quarter of 2026: Bengaluru up 90%, Mumbai up 64%, Delhi up 47%. Over those seven years that is about 9.6%, 7.3% and 5.7% a year (my own sums). We try 6% and 8%.
What happens after 20 years
Flat price grows at Flat is worth Renter's investments (₹26 lakh plus the monthly SIPs) Who is ahead ------------ 6% a year ₹3.21 crore ₹4.59 crore Renter, by ₹1.38 crore 8% a year ₹4.66 crore ₹4.59 crore Buyer, by ₹7 lakh (about even)
Break-even. With a 3% rental yield and a 10% SIP return, the flat must rise about 7.9% a year for buying to match renting. Prices have risen by more than that in Bengaluru and Hyderabad since 2019, and by less in Mumbai and Delhi.
The result moves a lot with the rent. If the same flat rents for ₹33,333 a month (a 4% yield), the renter's investments fall to ₹3.74 crore and the break-even price growth falls to about 6.8% a year. At ₹40,000 a month, buying wins even at 6% growth. A higher rent makes buying look better.
Key point: Buying beats renting only if the flat's price grows faster than your SIP, after you count the extra interest, the upfront costs and the cost of keeping the house. At a low rental yield, it needs about 8% a year.
What this simple comparison leaves out
- Taxes. The renter's corpus is before capital gains tax. A seller may also pay tax and brokerage. Interest on a loan for a home you live in gives a tax deduction of up to ₹2 lakh a year, but only under the old tax regime and subject to conditions. - After year 20. The buyer then lives rent-free. In this example the renter's rent would be about ₹63,000 a month by year 20 and still rising. The renter has a corpus to pay it from, but it is not free. - Discipline. The renter wins only if the full gap really goes into the SIP every month for 20 years. A home loan forces saving. Many people who rent do not invest the difference. - Interest paid. The buyer pays ₹1.67 crore in EMIs on an ₹80 lakh loan, so about ₹87 lakh is interest. - Choice and risk. A flat can fall in value or be hard to sell. A rented home is easy to leave. A bought home gives you stability and the freedom to change the house as you like. - Where you live. The calculation changes with the city, the locality and the exact rent, as the Anarock figures show.
A simple way to decide
1. Find the rental yield: yearly rent divided by the flat's price. Below about 3%, renting often looks cheaper in money terms, but yield alone does not decide it. 2. Ask how long you will stay. Under 5 to 7 years, the upfront costs make buying hard to win. 3. Check your EMI. A common guide is to keep all EMIs at or below about 40% of take-home pay. It is a guide, not a limit, so also think about your dependants and job stability. 4. Be honest about whether you would invest the difference each month. If not, the loan acts as forced savings. 5. Keep an emergency fund and your term insurance in place before taking on a large EMI.
Buying a home is also a life choice, not only a money one. Treat the numbers above as one input.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- https://www.businesstoday.in/personal-finance/real-estate/story/top-housing-markets-deliver-up-to-125-price-appreciation-rental-yields-rise-by-100-bps-anarock-547053-2026-08-04 - https://www.bajajamc.com/knowledge-centre/nifty-50-historical-returns - https://hellobanker.in/sbi-home-loan-interest-rate-october-2026/ - https://www.newsbytesapp.com/news/business/banks-update-home-loan-interest-rates-on-october-16-2026/tldr