Should you switch from a regular plan to a direct plan? What it saves over 20 years, and the tax and exit load you may pay to switch

Should you move your money from a regular plan to a direct plan of the same mutual fund? Usually yes, but the move counts as a sale, so you may owe tax on it. Here is what the switch costs, what you save, and a way to switch with little or no tax.

Regular plan and direct plan: what is the difference?

Both plans hold the same shares and have the same fund manager. The only difference is cost.

- Regular plan: the fund pays a commission to the agent, bank or app that sold it to you. That commission comes out of your returns every year through a higher expense ratio. - Direct plan: you buy straight from the fund house, so there is no commission. The expense ratio is lower. - The gap for equity funds is often about 0.5% to 1% a year, though it varies from fund to fund. Check both ratios in your fund's factsheet. (A recent SEBI rule change from April 2026 splits the fee into clearer parts, and I did not confirm how it changes this gap.) - The direct plan has its own NAV, which is higher than the regular plan's NAV. A higher NAV does not mean the fund is costlier. It only means that less money was taken out as fees over the years.

What the gap costs over 20 years

Why it matters A 1% yearly fee gap looks small. Over 20 years it can take about one-sixth of your final money.

Take ₹10 lakh invested once for 20 years. These are assumed returns for a calculation, not a forecast. For reference, a fund factsheet of Axis Mutual Fund shows the Nifty 500 total return index gave about 13.9% a year over 10 years to 30 June 2026. Other trackers show 13.7% to 14.9%, depending on the end date. I did not confirm this figure against the NSE index factsheet. A fund that tries to beat the index may do better or worse, and most funds in a category do not beat it every year. So the numbers below use a more cautious 12% for the direct plan.

Plan Assumed yearly return after costs ₹10 lakh becomes after 20 years --------- Direct plan 12% about ₹96.5 lakh Regular plan, 0.5% higher cost 11.5% about ₹88.2 lakh Regular plan, 1% higher cost 11% about ₹80.6 lakh

- You lose about ₹8.3 lakh with a 0.5% gap and about ₹15.8 lakh with a 1% gap. - Monthly SIPs show the same pattern. The longer you hold, the more the gap costs.

What the switch costs you

A switch from regular to direct is not a simple relabel. Tax law treats it as two steps: you sell the regular units, then you buy direct units with the money. So:

- Capital gains tax. Under the current rules for equity funds, a gain on units held for more than 12 months is taxed at 12.5% on the amount above ₹1.25 lakh of gains in a financial year. A gain on units held for 12 months or less is taxed at 20%. Rates were different in earlier years, and old articles may show them. Confirm the current rules with a tax adviser. - Exit load. SEBI removed the exit load on a switch from a regular plan to the direct plan of the same scheme in May 2025. Switching to a different scheme is not covered by that rule. Check your fund house's notice. - Holding period restarts. The new direct units count as a fresh purchase from the switch date. - ELSS funds. The 3-year lock-in still applies to each unit. You cannot switch units that are still locked.

A worked example

You put ₹10 lakh in a regular equity plan more than a year ago. It is now worth ₹14 lakh, so the gain is ₹4 lakh.

- Taxable gain: ₹4 lakh minus the ₹1.25 lakh yearly allowance = ₹2.75 lakh - Tax at 12.5%: about ₹34,375 (a little more with the 4% cess) - Yearly saving from a 1% lower fee on ₹14 lakh: about ₹14,000 in year one - You earn the tax back in about 2.5 years. Past that point the switch pays for itself, and the saving grows as the money grows.

A smaller gap or a shorter holding horizon changes this. If you plan to sell within a year or two, the switch may not be worth the tax.

How to cut or avoid the tax

- Switch in parts across years. Each financial year, you can book up to ₹1.25 lakh of equity gains with no tax. Switch a part of the units each year so that the gain stays within that allowance. Units are sold in the order you bought them (oldest first), so the oldest units go first. - Switch when the gain is small or there is a loss. A fund that is down needs little or no tax to switch. - Leave old money, change new money. Stop the SIP in the regular plan and start a new SIP in the direct plan. Your old units stay put and no tax arises. Only new money gets the lower cost. - Do not switch units locked in an ELSS. Wait for the lock-in to end.

How to switch

- Log in to the fund house's website or app, or use a direct-plan platform, and choose the switch option from regular plan to direct plan of the same scheme. - If you bought through an agent, you may need to tell the agent in writing to remove their code from the folio. - Check the capital gains statement that the fund house gives you before and after the switch.

When it is better to stay in the regular plan

A direct plan comes with no advice. If your agent gives real help, such as stopping you from selling in a crash or fixing your mix of funds, that help may be worth the fee. A fee-only adviser is another option: you hold the direct plan and pay the adviser openly, which is often cheaper. If the agent only sold you the fund and gives no service, there is no reason to keep paying the commission.

So, should you switch?

- Large balance, long horizon, no active advice: a switch, in tranches, is usually worth it. - Small gain or loss on the units: switch now, as the tax is small. - Big gain, short horizon: do the numbers first, or just start new SIPs in the direct plan.

Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Sources

- SEBI exit load change on regular-to-direct switch (16 May 2025): https://5paisa.com/news/sebi-eliminates-exit-loads-for-switching-from-regular-to-direct-mutual-fund-plans - Switching and tax overview: https://www.valueresearchonline.com/stories/228961/switch-regular-to-direct-mutual-fund-plan-tax-cost-how/ - Axis Nifty 500 Index Fund presentation (June 2026): https://www.axismf.com/1/5/1423/1484/1778/1782/PresentationAxisNifty500IndexFundJune2026.pdf - Expense ratio gap, direct vs regular: https://groww.in/blog/why-expense-ratio-of-a-mutual-fund-matters