Prepay your home loan or invest the extra money? A ₹50 lakh loan at 8.5%: what a ₹10,000 monthly prepayment saves versus the same amount in a SIP

Prepaying ₹10,000 a month on a ₹50 lakh home loan at 8.5% cuts a 20-year loan to under 13 years and saves about ₹21.8 lakh of interest. Putting the same ₹10,000 into a SIP beats that only if the SIP earns more than about 9.3% a year, after tax, for all 20 years. That is more than the loan's own rate, and nobody can promise it.

The setup

All numbers below are an example, not your loan. Change them to match your own.

- Loan: ₹50 lakh at 8.5% a year, 20 years - EMI: ₹43,391 a month - Interest if you only pay the EMI: about ₹54.1 lakh. In total you repay about ₹1.04 crore - Extra money: ₹10,000 a month, which you either put into the loan or into an equity SIP

In the first month, ₹35,417 of your EMI is interest and only ₹7,974 repays the loan. Early prepayments hit the loan balance when it is biggest, which is why they save so much.

Option A: prepay ₹10,000 a month

- The loan ends after 155 months, which is 12 years and 11 months, not 20 years. This assumes you keep the EMI the same and ask the lender to shorten the loan term, not lower the EMI - Total interest falls to about ₹32.4 lakh, so you save about ₹21.8 lakh - After the loan ends, you invest the freed EMI plus your ₹10,000 (₹53,391 a month) for the remaining 85 months

Prepaying is a guaranteed return equal to your loan rate. Every rupee you prepay stops costing 8.5% a year, with no market risk. Banks have not been allowed to charge a prepayment penalty on floating-rate home loans to individuals for some years. From 1 January 2026, new RBI directions extend this to all regulated lenders, including housing finance companies, for floating-rate loans to individuals for non-business purposes, on loans sanctioned or renewed from that date. A fixed-rate loan can still carry a charge, so check your loan agreement.

Option B: keep the loan and run a ₹10,000 SIP

- You pay the EMI for the full 20 years - You invest ₹10,000 a month for 240 months, which is ₹24 lakh in all

At the end of 20 years, both people are debt-free. The question is who has more money.

Who ends up richer?

I assumed the SIP money sits in an equity mutual fund and is sold once at the end. I took off long-term capital gains tax at 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh. In real life, units bought in the last 12 months before you sell pay a higher 20% short-term tax, and I ignored that, as well as exit loads and the fund's expense ratio. All three would lower the SIP result, so treat the break-even as an approximation.

Assumed return on equity Option A: prepay, then invest (net corpus) Option B: SIP, keep the loan (net corpus) Better option ------------ 6% a year ₹55.1 lakh ₹43.0 lakh Prepay, by ₹12.1 lakh 8% a year ₹58.8 lakh ₹53.3 lakh Prepay, by ₹5.5 lakh 10% a year ₹62.8 lakh ₹66.5 lakh SIP, by ₹3.7 lakh 12% a year ₹67.0 lakh ₹83.6 lakh SIP, by ₹16.6 lakh

The break-even is about 9.3% a year After tax, the SIP has to average about 9.3% a year for 20 years just to tie with prepaying. Before tax that is about 8.7%. Below that, prepaying wins. Above it, the SIP wins, but only if the market actually pays that.

These figures are my own calculation from the setup above. They treat returns as a smooth rate each year, which real markets never are.

What is a fair return to assume?

I did not pick 10% because it is round. The Nifty 50 index, which tracks India's 50 large companies, gave about 10% a year over both the 10 and the 15 years to late October 2026. These figures come from one data site (returnscreener.com) and are price returns, so they leave out dividends. A total-return figure would be somewhat higher. Another search showed slightly different figures, depending on the end date. I could not check the official total-return numbers from NSE Indices. An index is also not a fund you can buy: a real fund's costs and tracking gap lower what you get.

The recent past is weaker. The same site shows about 4.5% to 5.3% a year over the last 5 years, depending on the end date. That is why the table includes 6% and 8%. A single decent fund may do better or worse than the index. Treat these figures as assumptions for a calculation, not as a forecast.

So 10% is a reasonable middle case, not a forecast. At 10%, the SIP's edge is only ₹3.7 lakh over 20 years, while you carry the risk that returns come in at 6% or 8%.

Things that can change the answer

- Your loan rate. At 10% on the loan, prepaying becomes even more attractive. At 7%, the SIP wins at lower returns. - Tax benefit. For a self-occupied home, the old tax regime lets you claim up to ₹2 lakh a year of home loan interest as a deduction, if you meet the conditions. That lowers the real cost of the loan, which tilts the answer a little toward the SIP. The new regime does not give this deduction. I did not include the deduction in the table. - Your emergency fund. Prepaid money is hard to get back. Keep 6 months of expenses aside before you prepay anything. - Your temperament. A guaranteed 8.5% return, with no ups and downs, suits many people better than an uncertain higher one. - Other debt. A credit card or personal loan at 15% or more always comes first.

A simple middle path

You do not have to choose one side. Many people split the extra money, for example ₹5,000 to prepayment and ₹5,000 to a SIP. You get a smaller guaranteed saving and keep some exposure to the market. Also, if you receive a yearly bonus, prepaying with it once a year does most of the work with little effort.

Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Sources

- https://www.returnscreener.com/stocks/nifty50 - https://www.angelone.in/news/rbi-guidelines-on-loan-prepayment-charges-to-take-effect-from-january-1 - https://www.businesstoday.in/personal-finance/banking/story/rbi-removes-prepayment-charges-floating-rate-loans-2026-483120-2025-07-04 - https://www.freepressjournal.in/business/rbi-bans-pre-payment-charges-on-biz-loans-new-rules-to-help-individuals-mses-from-2026