Tata Capital: JM Financial says Buy at ₹400, Motilal Oswal says Neutral at ₹340 after Q2 profit rose 51%

Brokerages are split on Tata Capital after its September 2026 quarter. JM Financial says Buy with a ₹400 target. Motilal Oswal says Neutral with ₹340. The stock, at ₹319, sits between them.

Tata Capital (NSE: TATACAP, mainboard) - Share price: ₹319 (30 October 2026, delayed quote) - Market cap: about ₹1.35 lakh crore - P/E: about 22.7 times the last twelve months' profit, and 2.67 times book value - Return on equity: about 14%

Broker target call: JM Financial: Buy, target ₹400 vs ₹319 today (+25.4%)

The business

Tata Capital is the financial-services arm of the Tata group. It was incorporated on 8 March 1991 as Primal Investments & Finance and took the Tata Capital name on 8 May 2007. It lends to individuals and companies: car loans, home loans, personal loans, business loans and more. It listed on the stock exchanges on 13 October 2025.

Why the houses disagree

House Call Target Move from ₹319 ------------ JM Financial Buy ₹400 (2.8 times FY28 expected book value) +25.4% Motilal Oswal Neutral ₹340 +6.6%

- JM Financial's case: growth and asset quality are on track. A recovery in the net interest margin is the key trigger for profit upgrades, and it expects this as price rises on loans feed through. - Motilal Oswal's case: the outlook is good, but the current price already reflects near-term growth and earnings.

The September 2026 quarter

- Profit rose 51% to ₹1,660 crore from ₹1,097 crore. - Assets under management (AUM), which is its loan book, grew 26%. - Net interest income rose 23% to ₹3,700 crore. That is slower than AUM growth, because the margin fell. - The net interest margin fell by 9 basis points from the June quarter to about 4.9%. It was the fourth fall in a row, because the cost of borrowing rose faster than the rate it charges. - Management kept its guidance of 23% to 25% loan growth. It expects margin plus fees to be stable or slightly better in the December quarter, and a stronger recovery in the March quarter.

The shares rose about 5% at the day's high on 28 October on the results, then settled near ₹319 by 30 October.

The main risk

The margin has to turn. If it falls again, the profit upgrades JM Financial expects will not arrive, and the stock's 22.7 times P/E looks harder to defend.

A target price is the broker's opinion, not a promise.

Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Sources

- https://www.business-standard.com/markets/news/tata-capital-share-price-jump-5-post-q2-show-analysts-say-margin-revival-key-1261028005741.html - https://www.freepressjournal.in/business/tata-capital-share-price-jumps-nearly-5-after-q2-profit-surges-51 - https://stockanalysis.com/quote/nse/TATACAP/statistics/