Your mutual fund trailed its index for two years: when to switch and when to hold?
Your equity mutual fund has returned less than its index for two years. Should you sell and switch? In most cases, two years of lagging is a reason to check the fund, not a reason to sell it.
Here is a simple way to check, and the costs of switching that people forget.
First, are you comparing it with the right thing?
A fund can only be called a laggard against the right yardstick. Check three things:
- The fund's own benchmark. Every scheme names one in its factsheet. Since 2018, SEBI has required funds to compare themselves with a total return index (TRI). A TRI counts dividends as well as price gains, so it is a fairer test than a plain price index. A small-cap fund should be compared with a small-cap index, not the Nifty 50. - The category average. If most funds in the same category also lagged, the cause is probably the market and not your fund. A fund that lags while its peers do well is a bigger worry. - The same dates. A one-day or one-month comparison tells you very little. Use the same start and end date for the fund, the index and the peers.
Compare the plan you own with the same type of plan. A regular plan pays a higher expense ratio than a direct plan, so the same portfolio returns a little less in the regular plan. Compare like with like.
Two years is short. Look at rolling returns
Rolling returns take many overlapping periods, for example every 3-year stretch in the last 10 years, and show how often the fund beat its benchmark. One bad patch then does not hide a good record.
Rules of thumb often used by advisers and fund-research sites (these are not SEBI rules, and different sources use different numbers):
- Lagging for one or two years: start watching. - Lagging for three to five years, or in most rolling periods: take it seriously. - Some fund-research writers use a count of rolling periods (for example, beating the benchmark in most but not all of them) or about two and a half years of steady lagging as a warning line. Sources differ, so treat any such number as a guide only. Also note that rolling periods overlap, and a young fund has too little history for this test.
An investment style can also go out of favour for a time. A manager who buys cheap, unloved shares may trail in a market led by expensive growth shares, and then catch up. Business Standard has argued that a fund that is still doing what it promised should not be dropped only for lagging.
Signs that point to a real problem
Sign What to check Why it matters --------- Fund manager left Who took over? Did the research team and the way the fund picks shares stay the same? A new manager can mean new rules for picking shares, but not always. Treat it as a reason to review, not an automatic sell Style drift Does the portfolio still match the fund's category and stated approach? A fund that no longer does what you bought it for is the wrong tool Lags both benchmark and peers Rolling returns against both The problem is the fund, not the market Fund has grown very large Has the AMC limited new money, or does it hold fewer small stocks? Size matters most for small-cap and mid-cap funds, where shares are harder to buy and sell in bulk. It matters less for large-cap funds Costs went up Expense ratio now versus two years ago and versus similar funds Higher costs reduce every year's return, but a small rise alone is not a reason to exit
Dhirendra Kumar of Value Research has said he would sell a fund that cannot beat its benchmark, and he points to funds that stay at the bottom of their category for two years running. The key point is that the lag must persist, not that it appeared once.
What switching costs
Selling a fund is a taxable event. Under the current rules for equity-oriented funds:
Holding period (equity-oriented fund) Tax on profit ------ 12 months or less 20% More than 12 months 12.5% on profit above ₹1.25 lakh a year
- Many funds charge an exit load if you sell within a set time (often around 1% within a year, but it varies and some funds charge none). Check your scheme's rule before you sell. - If you run a SIP, each instalment has its own purchase date. Recent instalments may carry tax at the higher rate and an exit load. Older units are sold first. - Switching is a sale followed by a purchase at two separate prices (NAVs), so your money is briefly out of the market and you can miss a move in between. - Stopping a SIP and selling the units you already hold are two different things. You can stop new instalments without selling anything, and that triggers no tax.
An illustration (made-up numbers, not a real fund). You hold ₹5 lakh of an equity fund for three years and it is now worth ₹6 lakh. You sell. The profit is ₹1 lakh, which is under the ₹1.25 lakh yearly tax-free limit, so tax is nil, assuming you have no other long-term equity profit that year. Now suppose the profit was ₹3 lakh instead. The taxable part is ₹1.75 lakh and tax at 12.5% is about ₹21,900, plus 4% cess. (Surcharge, which applies at high incomes, is not included.) The new fund must beat the old one by enough to cover that bill before you are better off.
The rule to remember A fund that trails its benchmark for two years deserves a review. It deserves a sale only if the reason is lasting, such as a new manager with a new style, higher costs, or years of lagging both its benchmark and its peers.
A simple checklist before you sell
1. Write down the fund's benchmark and its category. 2. Check rolling 3-year returns against both, not only the latest 1-year or 2-year figure. 3. Find out if the manager, the strategy, the size or the expense ratio changed. 4. Work out the tax and exit load you would pay on today's value. 5. Decide where the money would go, and why that choice is better. If you cannot say why, hold and review again in six months. 6. If you do switch, avoid chasing last year's top fund. Past returns do not carry forward.
If you hold several funds from the same category, also check whether they overlap heavily. Sometimes the better move is to stop adding to one fund and let the other take new SIP money, which costs no tax.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- SEBI's move to total return benchmarks, January 2018: https://www.business-standard.com/amp/article/pti-stories/adopt-total-return-index-to-benchmark-schemes-sebi-to-mfs-1180104008731.html - SEBI total return index benchmark note: https://www.morningstar.in/posts/44272/benchmark-equity-schemes-against-tri-sebi.aspx - Dhirendra Kumar on when to sell a fund: https://www.businesstoday.in/mutual-funds/story/if-a-fund-cant-beat-its-benchmark-i-will-sell-it-dhirendra-kumar-on-when-to-switch-sell-mutual-funds-506530-2025-12-13 - Value Research on signs it is time to exit: https://www.valueresearchonline.com/stories/227788/underperforming-mutual-fund-5-signs-its-time-to-exit-it/ - Business Standard on not quitting an underperformer that stays true to its mandate: https://www.business-standard.com/amp/article/pf/don-t-quit-underperformer-if-fund-manager-remains-true-to-mandate-1221213010921.html