NAV in a mutual fund: why a ₹12 NAV fund is not cheaper than a ₹400 one

Is a mutual fund with a ₹12 NAV cheaper than one with a ₹400 NAV? Many first-time investors think so. They are wrong, and this one habit can send your money to the wrong fund.

What NAV actually is

NAV stands for net asset value. It tells you the value of one unit of a mutual fund on a given day.

The fund adds up the value of everything it owns, subtracts its expenses and other dues, and divides what is left by the total number of units.

- NAV = (total assets - total liabilities) / total units issued - A fund owning ₹100 crore of assets with 10 crore units has a NAV of ₹10. - The NAV is generally published every business day, after the market closes.

NAV is not a quality score. It is not a "price tag" that says how expensive the fund is. It only tells you how many fund units your money buys today.

Same return, different NAV: an illustrative example

The numbers below are illustrative. They are not real funds.

Say you invest ₹10,000 in each of two funds. Fund A has a NAV of ₹12. Fund B has a NAV of ₹400. Both funds then rise 10% over the next year.

Fund A (low NAV) Fund B (high NAV) --------- NAV when you buy ₹12 ₹400 Units you get about 833.33 25 NAV after a 10% rise ₹13.20 ₹440 Value of your money about ₹11,000 ₹11,000

You end up with about the same ₹11,000. The low NAV fund gave you more units, but each unit was worth less. In this example, your gain depends on the percentage change in NAV, not on whether the NAV starts at ₹12 or ₹400. (Real returns can also change with exit load, tax and the timing of your buy and sell.)

Remember this A low NAV does not mean a cheap fund, and a high NAV does not mean an expensive one. Compare what the fund earns in percentage, not the number on its NAV.

The "₹10 NFO" myth

When a new fund launches in an NFO, units are usually offered at ₹10 each. This can look like a bargain next to an older fund at ₹80 or ₹400.

It is not a bargain. ₹10 is only the usual starting price of a unit in a new fund. An older fund may have a higher NAV because its investments have grown in value over the years. That is not a sign that it is expensive.

A new fund also has no history. You cannot see how it did when the stock market fell. An older fund, whatever its NAV, gives you more facts to judge.

So what should you compare instead?

Look at these, not at the NAV:

- Returns over several years, compared with funds in the same category and with the fund's benchmark index. Use CAGR for a fair comparison of lump-sum returns. - Expense ratio: the yearly fee the fund charges. A lower fee leaves more of the return with you. - Risk: how much the fund fell in past market downturns, not only how much it gained. - Portfolio: which stocks and other investments the fund owns, and whether the money is spread out. - Fund manager: how long the manager has run the fund and how it did during that time. - Exit load: a fee you may pay if you take your money out before a set period.

Does NAV matter at all?

Yes, in two small ways.

- Checking your own gain: your profit is simply (today's NAV - your buy NAV) x your units. This is how you track your fund. - Understanding a payout: when a fund pays out money under its IDCW (dividend) option, its NAV generally falls by the amount paid per unit. You receive cash, but the value of your remaining units goes down by the same amount. The payout may also be taxed.

In a SIP, your monthly amount buys units at the NAV of that day. When the NAV is low you get more units, and when it is high you get fewer. This helps average your buying cost over time. It does not guarantee a profit or protect you from a loss.

A simple checklist before you buy

- Ignore the NAV number when you choose a fund. - Check the fund's long-term return against its category and benchmark. - Check the expense ratio. - Read what the fund holds. - Use the NAV only to track your own gain after you invest.

Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Sources

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netassetvalue - https://www.amfiindia.com/