Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana or a mutual fund SIP for your daughter: ₹10,000 a month for 15 years at 8.2% versus an equity fund
You want to save ₹10,000 a month for your daughter. Two popular choices are the government's Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) account at 8.2%, and a mutual fund SIP in an equity index fund. The government announces the Sukanya rate every quarter. The return from a stock-market SIP is not guaranteed: it could be higher or lower. So which one builds more money after 21 years?
Short answer: if the 8.2% rate stayed the same for all 21 years, the Sukanya account would give about ₹55 lakh from ₹18 lakh paid in, tax-free. This is a projection, not a promise. An equity SIP beats it only if the fund earns more than about 9% a year (before the tax you pay when you sell). Over the last 15 years, the Nifty 50 index averaged 12% a year. Over the last 5 years, it averaged only 6.4%.
The numbers: ₹10,000 a month for 15 years
You pay in for 15 years, which is ₹18 lakh in total. Then you leave the money alone until year 21, when a Sukanya account matures.
Sukanya account SIP at 8% SIP at 10% SIP at 12% --------------- Total paid in ₹18 lakh ₹18 lakh ₹18 lakh ₹18 lakh Value at year 21 (before tax) ₹55.5 lakh ₹53.9 lakh ₹71.1 lakh ₹93.9 lakh Tax on gains None ₹4.5 lakh ₹6.7 lakh ₹9.7 lakh Value after tax ₹55.5 lakh ₹49.4 lakh ₹64.4 lakh ₹84.2 lakh
How I worked this out: the Sukanya figure assumes 8.2% for all 21 years, with interest added once a year. The SIP figures assume a fixed yearly return of 8%, 10% or 12%, with the money invested at the start of each month. The tax figure assumes you sell everything in one year and pay 12.5% plus 4% cess (13% in all) on gains above ₹1.25 lakh (the rule for equity funds held over one year in 2026-27, with no surcharge). The ₹1.25 lakh is one yearly limit for all your equity gains, not one per fund. Real index funds earn a little less than the index because of costs. If you sell in parts over several years, you can use the ₹1.25 lakh exemption each year and pay a little less tax. These are assumptions for a calculation, not forecasts.
What the Sukanya account is
- It is a government savings account for a girl child. It can be opened until she turns 10. - You can pay in from ₹250 to ₹1.5 lakh a year, for 15 years counted from the day the account is opened. - The account matures 21 years after opening. - The interest rate is set by the Finance Ministry every quarter. It is 8.2% for October to December 2026, unchanged for the ninth quarter in a row. - Money paid in qualifies for the Section 80C tax deduction (up to ₹1.5 lakh a year, in the old tax regime only), and the interest and the maturity money are tax-free. - After she turns 18, a part of the balance (up to 50%) can be taken out for higher education or marriage. You need to show proof, such as an admission letter.
Rules can change and websites differ on small details, so confirm the latest rules at your bank or post office before you open the account.
What equity actually earned
Here is what two broad stock indices returned each year, on average, up to 30 September 2026. These are total-return figures: they include both the change in share prices and the dividends paid.
Period Nifty 50 Nifty 500 --------- 1 year −7.1% −2.0% 3 years 6.1% 9.5% 5 years 6.4% 9.0% 10 years 11.5% 12.8% 15 years 12.0% 13.3%
Look at both ends. Over 15 years, equity beat 8.2% by a wide margin. Over the last 5 years, the Nifty 50 earned less than the Sukanya account. A SIP at 6.4% for 15 years would have grown to only about ₹43 lakh at year 21, well below ₹55 lakh. Long periods usually reward equity, but "usually" is not "always".
The catch on each side
Sukanya: - The rate is not fixed for 21 years. The government can change it each quarter. A lower average rate of 7% would give about ₹47 lakh instead of ₹55 lakh. - Money is mostly locked in. Only a part can be taken out early, for set reasons, and you need proof. - There is a cap of ₹1.5 lakh a year, so it cannot hold all of a large saving.
Equity SIP: - The value can fall a lot in a bad year, and you cannot know the return in advance. - You pay tax on the gain when you sell. - You need to keep investing when the market falls. Many people stop.
The break-even rule: For ₹10,000 a month over this period, the equity SIP needs to earn about 8.9% a year (before the tax you pay when you sell) to match the tax-free Sukanya account. Even with no tax at all, it would need 8.2%. Anything above that is the reward for taking the risk. Anything below it is the cost of the risk.
A simple way to decide
- Your daughter's education is the goal and the date is fixed: put at least part of the money in Sukanya. It is safe, tax-free and the rate is high for a government product. - You can wait 15 years or more and stay calm in a fall: put the rest in an equity index fund SIP. - Not sure? A split of half and half (₹5,000 in each) gives about ₹55 lakh at 8% equity returns, ₹63 lakh at 10% and ₹75 lakh at 12%. The Sukanya part is tax-free, and the equity part is shown before tax. If equity averages 8% or more, the split does about as well as Sukanya alone, with some upside if equity does better. - Keep your emergency fund and insurance in place first. Never use the child's savings to cover your own gaps.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.