Two investors, same ₹10,000 a month: one picks PPF, the other a Nifty 50 index fund. What that one choice did to their money after 5 years
This is an example, not a real person's story. Meera and Rohan are made up. The Nifty 50 returns and the PPF rate below are real.
Meera and Rohan are both 30. On 1 January 2021 each starts saving ₹10,000 a month. They have the same money and the same start date. One thing differs.
- Meera puts her ₹10,000 into a Public Provident Fund (PPF) account. PPF pays 7.1% a year and the rate has not changed since April 2020. The government reviews it every three months, so it can change. - Rohan puts his ₹10,000 into a Nifty 50 index fund through a monthly SIP. The fund invests in the companies of the Nifty 50 index, which tracks 50 large Indian companies.
Neither of them changes anything for five years. What did that one choice do to their money by December 2025?
What each of them ended up with
Meera (PPF) Rohan (Nifty 50 index fund) --------- Money put in over 5 years ₹6,00,000 ₹6,00,000 Value on 31 December 2025 about ₹7,18,000 about ₹8,33,000 Gain about ₹1,18,000 about ₹2,33,000 Gain on money put in about 20% about 39% Yearly return (XIRR) about 7.1% about 13.1%
Rohan is ahead by about ₹1,15,000. He earned about twice what Meera did.
How I worked this out. I used the real Nifty 50 total returns for each calendar year (this counts dividends too). I assumed each year's return was earned evenly through the 12 months. A real SIP would do a little better or worse depending on what the market did month by month. The index fund's small yearly fee is not included. For PPF I used 7.1% a year on the monthly balance, added to the account at the end of each year.
The five years, year by year
Year Nifty 50 return Meera's value at year end Rohan's value at year end Rohan's lead --------------- 2021 +25.6% ₹1,24,600 ₹1,36,100 ₹11,400 2022 +5.7% ₹2,58,100 ₹2,67,500 ₹9,400 2023 +21.3% ₹4,01,000 ₹4,57,900 ₹56,900 2024 +10.1% ₹5,54,100 ₹6,30,600 ₹76,500 2025 +11.9% ₹7,18,100 ₹8,33,300 ₹1,15,200
2021: a strong start for Rohan
The market rose 25.6%. Rohan's first 12 instalments grew to ₹1,36,100 against Meera's ₹1,24,600. His lead was small because most of his money had only been invested for part of the year.
2022: the lead almost disappears
The Nifty 50 rose only 5.7% in 2022. Rohan's lead shrank to ₹9,400, the smallest of the five years. Anyone who had judged him after two years would have said the index fund was barely better than PPF. Meera's money grew at a steady 7.1% in every year, and it never had a bad one.
2023 to 2025: the lead grows
The index rose 21.3%, 10.1% and 11.9% in the next three years. Because Rohan had already built up a large pot, each good year added more rupees than the one before. His lead grew to ₹1,15,200.
And where are they today?
The Nifty 50 closed at 25,291 on 16 November 2026. Its price at the end of 2025 was 26,130, so it is about 3% lower this year. This is the price index, which leaves out dividends of about 1% a year, so my 2026 figures are rough. Rohan's pot from the five years, left untouched, would be about ₹8,07,000 today. Meera's pot, left untouched, would have grown to about ₹7,63,000 (7.1% for about 10½ more months, a rough estimate). These are my estimates, and they ignore any new instalments. Rohan's lead is about ₹44,000 now, down from ₹1,15,000.
The fall in 2026 is a real reminder: Rohan's number goes down in a bad year. Meera's does not.
What the choice also changed
PPF Index fund SIP --------- Return Set by the government and reviewed every three months. 7.1% for now Not fixed. It followed the market Tax on gains Interest is tax-free Gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year are taxed at 12.5% (plus cess) when sold Lock-in 15 years, counted from the end of the year you open it, with limited early withdrawal None. Can be sold any day, but the price may be low Yearly limit ₹1.5 lakh a year No limit
If Rohan sold all his units at the end of 2025, the tax would depend on when each unit was bought. Units held for more than a year are taxed at 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year. Units held for less than a year are taxed at 20%. Cess of 4% is added. As a worst case, suppose his whole gain of about ₹2,33,000 was taxed at 20%. The tax would be about ₹46,600, and he would still be about ₹68,000 ahead of Meera. The real tax would be lower.
What this example shows Over these five years the index fund beat PPF by about 6 percentage points a year. But the lead was only ₹9,400 after two years, and it fell again in 2026. Equity can pay more over long periods, but there is no promise, and it does not pay more every year.
What this teaches
- The result depends on the years you pick. 2021 to 2025 was a good stretch for Indian shares. Other five-year periods have been much weaker. For example, the Nifty 50's price rose only 3.0% in 2016 and fell 4.1% in 2015, according to rupeecase.com's table of yearly returns. I did not test other start dates. - A short period can show a small gap. After two years, Rohan was barely ahead. Anyone who had stopped his SIP then would have missed the three good years that followed. - PPF is not a bad choice. Its interest is tax-free and backed by the government, and it suits money you cannot afford to lose. The cost is lower growth, a long lock-in, and a rate that can change. - Money needed within three years does not belong in an index fund. A fall like 2026 could hit just when it is needed. - Many people use both. A part in PPF for safety, a part in an index fund for growth.
Past returns do not promise future returns. The numbers above show what happened from 2021 to 2025. They are not a forecast for the next five years.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- https://www.bajajamc.com/knowledge-centre/nifty-50-historical-returns (Nifty 50 total returns by calendar year) - https://www.rupeecase.com/guides/nifty-50-returns-by-year (Nifty 50 price returns by year, cross-check) - https://www.freepressjournal.in/business/small-savings-interest-rates-unchanged-for-oct-dec-ppf-at-71-per-cent-nsc-at-77-pc (PPF at 7.1%, October to December 2026) - https://vicky.bankbazaar.com/saving-schemes/know-about-ppf-interest-rate.html (PPF rate by quarter since 2020) - https://www.kotakneo.com/news/market-news/sensex-and-nifty-finish-in-the-positive/ (Nifty 50 close, 16 November 2026)