Two investors, same ₹10,000 a month: one stops his SIP in the March 2020 crash, the other keeps going. Who is ahead after 3 years, and by how much?
Asha and Bala start the same ₹10,000-a-month SIP in a Nifty 50 index fund in January 2020. Three years later, their accounts look very different. One decision made the gap: what each did when the market crashed in March 2020. Read on to see how big the gap is.
This is an example, not a real person's story. Asha and Bala are made-up names. The market numbers are real. They are month-end closing values of the Nifty 50 from January 2020 to December 2022.
The two investors
- Asha starts a ₹10,000 SIP on the Nifty 50 in January 2020. She never stops it. - Bala starts the same SIP on the same day. In March 2020 the market falls fast and he stops. He restarts in January 2021, when the market has recovered above where he began. - Both stop looking at their account in December 2022, after 36 months.
What the market did
Month-end Nifty 50 What happened --------- Dec 2019 12,168 Before they start Jan 2020 11,962 Both start Mar 2020 8,598 Covid crash. Down 29% from Dec 2019 Dec 2020 13,982 Fully recovered. Bala is still on pause Jan 2021 13,635 Bala restarts Dec 2022 18,105 End of the example
At the March 2020 month-end close (the market dipped even lower during the month), Asha had put in ₹30,000 and her units were worth about ₹24,900. She was down about ₹5,100 on paper. Bala saw a similar number and stopped.
What each did, and what it cost
Bala skipped ten instalments, March to December 2020. Those were the cheapest months to buy. The Nifty was at 8,598 in March and 9,860 in April, and Bala bought none of it.
Asha's ₹10,000 bought about 1.16 units of the index at the March 2020 level. The same ₹10,000 bought only about 0.73 units in January 2021, when Bala restarted at 13,635.
The result after 36 months
Asha Bala --------- Instalments paid 36 26 Money put in ₹3,60,000 ₹2,60,000 Value on 31 Dec 2022 ₹4,60,851 ₹2,94,150 Gain in rupees ₹1,00,851 ₹34,150 Gain on money put in 28.0% 13.1% Yearly return on the money (XIRR, my calculation from all 36 month-end closes) about 17.6% about 11.4%
Asha's gain is about three times Bala's. But Bala also put in ₹1,00,000 less, so the final values are not a fair comparison on their own.
Suppose Bala saved every skipped instalment and kept those ten ₹10,000 instalments in a savings account at 3% a year. By the end of 2022 that money would be about ₹1,07,000. His total would then be about ₹4,01,000, against Asha's ₹4,60,851. So the pause still cost him roughly ₹60,000, even after counting the savings interest. This 3% rate and the assumption that he saves all of it are mine, for illustration.
A fair warning
This example happened in a very kind period. The market fell sharply and then recovered within months. Nifty 50 rose 49% from December 2019 to December 2022, about 14% a year. That is the price index only. It leaves out dividends and fund costs, and Yahoo Finance's month-end closes are used as the price for each instalment.
If the market had kept falling for years, Bala's pause would have looked wiser, at least for a while. Nobody can know in advance. That is the point of an SIP. It buys on a fixed date so that you do not have to guess.
An index fund's own returns will also differ a little from the index. The three years from 2020 to 2022 are not a forecast for the next three. Past returns do not promise future returns.
What this teaches
- An SIP works best in the months that feel worst, because the same ₹10,000 buys more units. - Stopping an SIP in a fall locks in the one thing you did not want: buying fewer units when prices are low. - Waiting to "feel safe" before you restart often means restarting at a higher price. Bala restarted 59% above the March 2020 month-end close. - If you must pause, set a date to restart, not a feeling.
The key point Both investors owned the same fund. The only difference was what each did in a crash. The one who kept investing ended with about ₹60,000 more, even after giving the other the interest on his skipped instalments.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/%5ENSEI/history/ (Nifty 50 monthly closes, January 2020 to December 2022) - https://www.niftyindices.com/indices/equity/broad-based-indices/nifty-50 (index details)