Invest Now or Wait for a 10% Fall? Two SIP Investors Over 5 Years
Asha invests ₹10,000 every month. Bhavin saves the same amount and waits for the market to fall 10% first. Who has more after 5 years?
This is an example, not a real person's story. Asha and Bhavin are made-up names. The market numbers are real: they are the month-end closing values of the Nifty 50 index, from December 2020 to December 2025.
Asha and Bhavin: same money, one different rule
Both start in December 2020 with the same salary and the same plan to put ₹10,000 a month towards equity. Over 60 months, each of them sets aside ₹6 lakh.
- Asha invests ₹10,000 in a Nifty 50 index fund at the end of every month. She does not look at the market. - Bhavin feels the market is too high. He saves ₹10,000 a month in his bank account. He has one rule: when the Nifty closes a month at least 10% below its highest month-end close so far, he puts all his saved cash into the index fund. After that he invests ₹10,000 every month, like Asha.
To keep it simple, I use the Nifty 50 price index as a stand-in for an index fund. It leaves out dividends and fund costs, and both of them would have been affected in the same way. I also assume Bhavin's savings earn no interest. I come back to that below.
What the market did
From 31 December 2020 to 31 December 2025, the Nifty 50 went from 13,981.75 to 26,129.60. That is a gain of about 87%, or about 13.3% a year, before dividends. This is only what happened in these five years. It is not a promise for the next five.
The road was not smooth:
- The Nifty reached 18,477 on 18 October 2021. It then fell to 15,293 by 17 June 2022, a drop of 17% - On 30 June 2022 the month ended at 15,780. That is more than 10% below the highest month-end close up to then, 17,672 (October 2021) - It rose to a new high of 26,216 on 26 September 2024, then fell about 16% to 22,083 by 4 March 2025
What happened to Bhavin's rule
Bhavin waited for 18 months. His bank balance grew by ₹10,000 each month while the Nifty went up. The 10% fall arrived with the month-end close of 30 June 2022. By then he had ₹1.9 lakh in the bank. He put it all in at 15,780. After that he invested ₹10,000 a month.
Asha, in the same 18 months, had put in the same ₹1.9 lakh bit by bit. At 30 June 2022 her ₹1.9 lakh was worth about ₹1.87 lakh. So in the short run, Asha was slightly behind, and Bhavin's patience looked clever.
Result after 5 years: who had more?
Both of them had put in ₹6 lakh by the end of November 2025. On 31 December 2025:
Asha (invests every month) Bhavin (waits for a 10% fall) --------- Money put in ₹6.00 lakh ₹6.00 lakh Value on 31 Dec 2025 ₹8.15 lakh ₹8.19 lakh Gain ₹2.15 lakh (35.8%) ₹2.19 lakh (36.6%) Average Nifty level at which the money went in 19,241 19,131 Yearly return, counting each monthly payment from its own date (XIRR) about 12.2% about 12.4%
Bhavin came out ahead by about ₹4,700, or 0.6%. That is almost no difference. If Bhavin's bank balance had earned 3% a year while he waited (added to the balance every month, before tax), his final value would have been about ₹8.27 lakh, so his lead would be about ₹12,000.
The lesson in one line Waiting for a fall paid off here only because the fall came after 18 months, and it was a deep one. Nobody knew that in December 2020.
The same two rules in other periods
The result depends on when you start. I ran the same two rules from three other start dates, to the end of 2025. In each case, Bhavin waits for the first month-end close that is 10% below the highest so far, and the money in the table is the gain over what each of them put in.
Start Months Bhavin's 10% fall came Asha's gain Bhavin's gain Winner ------------------ Dec 2020 60 June 2022 (18 months) 35.8% 36.6% Bhavin, barely Dec 2021 48 Feb 2025 (38 months) 27.7% 15.7% Asha Dec 2022 36 Feb 2025 (26 months) 19.8% 14.9% Asha Dec 2023 24 Feb 2025 (14 months) 9.5% 13.2% Bhavin
When the start date was in December 2021, Bhavin waited 38 months for his fall, while the Nifty climbed from 17,354 to above 25,000. He ended with about 12 percentage points less gain than Asha.
These four periods overlap a lot, so they are not four separate tests. They show how much the answer changes with the start date. They do not show how often waiting for a 10% fall beats a monthly SIP.
What this teaches
- A 10% fall is not on a timetable. Bhavin waited 14 months in one period and 38 months in another - When the money sits in a bank account, it does not grow with the market. Interest of about 3% is far below what the index did in this period - Asha's way needs no forecast. She got a similar result in the first period and a much better one in two of the others - Waiting can still win. It depends on the dip coming early and being deep, and that is luck - If you cannot sleep while investing at a high, a middle path exists. Invest half your monthly amount and keep half for dips. It is a choice about comfort, not a way to beat the market
Past returns do not promise future returns. The index may behave differently in the next five years. The numbers here are for explaining an idea only.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- https://query1.finance.yahoo.com/v8/finance/chart/%5ENSEI?period1=1604102400&period2=1767312000&interval=1mo (Nifty 50 month-end closes) - https://query1.finance.yahoo.com/v8/finance/chart/%5ENSEI?period1=1604102400&period2=1767312000&interval=1d (Nifty 50 daily closes, used for the peaks and falls)