Why direct plan NAV looks “more expensive” than regular plan — and why that’s backwards
If you've ever compared two mutual fund options and noticed the "direct plan" has a higher NAV than the "regular plan" of the exact same scheme, you've probably wondered: doesn't a higher NAV mean it's more expensive? It's the single most-asked question by first-time mutual fund investors in India — and the intuition is backwards.
Same fund, two price tags
A direct plan and a regular plan of the same scheme hold the exact same portfolio — same fund manager, same stocks or bonds, same investment strategy. The only difference is distribution: a regular plan is bought through a distributor or advisor, who earns a commission from the fund house; a direct plan is bought straight from the AMC, with no distributor in between.
That commission comes out of the scheme's assets as part of its expense ratio — typically 0.5% to 1.5% higher per year for a regular plan versus its direct twin. Because expenses are deducted before NAV is calculated, the direct plan's NAV compounds a little higher every single day. A higher direct-plan NAV isn't a sign of anything being "pricier" — it's the visible result of lower costs, not higher ones.
What that gap actually costs you
Small annual percentages sound trivial until you run them over a real time horizon. Take a ₹10,000 monthly SIP for 20 years, assuming a 12% gross annual return before fees — a reasonable long-term assumption, since the Nifty 50's own 20-year TRI CAGR has run close to that level (~12.44% as of March 2026, per NSE Indices data):
Plan type Expense ratio 20-year corpus (illustrative) --------- Direct, index fund ~0.10% ~₹1.00 crore Direct, active fund ~0.50% ~₹98.9 lakh Regular, active fund ~1.50% ~₹85.4 lakh
On the same ₹24 lakh invested over 20 years, the gap between a regular and a direct plan of a similar active fund works out to roughly ₹13-14 lakh — money that went to commissions, not to your goal. That's not a rounding error; it's more than half of everything you put in.
The one-line version A regular plan's NAV looks "cheaper" only because it has already lost more to fees — over decades, that gap compounds into lakhs of rupees that never reach your goal.
So why does anyone still buy regular plans?
A regular plan isn't a mistake for everyone. If you rely on a distributor or advisor for hand-holding — fund selection, rebalancing reminders, help during a market crash when you're tempted to panic-sell — that advice has real value, and the commission is effectively how you're paying for it. The problem is buying a regular plan without realizing you're paying for a service you're not using.
If you're comfortable picking funds yourself, tracking your portfolio, and staying invested through volatility without hand-holding, a direct plan captures that entire cost difference for you, every year, compounding.
How to tell which one you're in
Your account statement or the app you invest through will explicitly say "Direct Plan" or "Regular Plan" next to the scheme name — if it just says "Growth" or "Dividend" with no "Direct"/"Regular" tag, check with your platform, since some apps default to regular. If you started investing through a bank RM, a distributor app, or an insurance-linked advisor, you're very likely in regular plans. Platforms built for self-directed investors (most direct-only apps) default to direct plans.
Switching an existing regular-plan investment to direct isn't automatic — it usually involves a redemption-and-reinvestment (which can trigger capital gains tax and, for equity funds redeemed within a year, exit load) or, for some funds, a documented "plan conversion" request that avoids that, so check with the AMC before assuming it's a free switch.
Note: I am not a SEBI-registered investment advisor. This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Please consult a registered financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- https://zerodha.com/varsity/chapter/mutual-fund-expense-ratio-direct-and-regular-plans/ - https://www.whalesbook.com/news/English/personal-finance/Mutual-Fund-Fees-Small-Costs-Can-Erase-indian-rupee20-Lakhs-Over-20-Years/6a0ec23ce28c1d234356e67d - https://investwithmithun.com/direct-vs-regular-mutual-funds/ - https://www.bajajamc.com/knowledge-centre/nifty-50-historical-returns